Welcome to Gatto’s Pizza
At Gatto's Pizza, the heart of Columbus dining, we proudly carry on a legacy of over 50 years, delivering the perfect blend of flavor and nostalgia. Nestled on Indianola Avenue, our pizzeria specializes in Columbus-style pizza, featuring a thin, crunchy crust cut into squares. Guests rave about our house-made sausage and perfectly balanced toppings, including options like pepperoni and banana peppers. With a commitment to quality and a welcoming atmosphere, we cater to all, offering delivery and dine-in experiences. Join us for a slice, and discover why many consider Gatto's the best pizza in the city.
-
3420 Indianola Ave Columbus, OH 43214 United States Hotline: (614) 263-3737
Welcome to the vibrant world of Gatto’s Pizza, a delightful pizzeria nestled in the heart of Columbus, Ohio, on Indianola Avenue. Since its establishment over 50 years ago, Gatto’s has carved out a niche for itself, becoming a beloved favorite among locals and pizza enthusiasts alike.
Walking into Gatto's Pizza, you are greeted by a charming atmosphere designed for casual dining. The establishment is wheelchair accessible and offers a range of seating options including outdoor areas, perfect for those warm summer evenings. With moderate noise levels and amenities such as free Wi-Fi, it’s an excellent spot for both family dinners and group outings.
One of the standout features of Gatto's is its commitment to quality. The thin crust pizza, which is a hallmark of the Columbus pizza style, boasts a delightful crunch, while being generously topped with flavorful ingredients. As outlined in customer testimonials, the house-made sausage and the classic pepperoni are definite crowd-pleasers. Patrons rave about the perfectly blended sauce and the array of toppings, including fan favorites like banana peppers, that elevate each slice.
- Delivery and Takeout Options: Gatto's Pizza offers efficient delivery and takeout services, making it a convenient choice for those nights when you crave fresh, hot pizza at home.
- Online Ordering: With a user-friendly online ordering system, placing your pizza cravings at the forefront has never been more accessible.
- Good for Kids: The menu is family-friendly, ensuring even the youngest pizza lovers find something to enjoy.
- Catering Services: Hosting a gathering? Gatto's provides catering options that promise to impress your guests.
- Pet-friendly Dining: With a welcoming stance on dogs in outdoor areas, Fido can accompany you for a pizza night too!
The ambiance is complemented by the selection of local beers and a modest wine list, perfect for pairing with your meal. Happy hour specials add to the allure, making it an ideal locale to unwind after a busy day. With the kitchen’s devotion to using quality ingredients and their craft in making their own sauces, it's clear that Gatto's prioritizes flavor.
What sets Gatto’s apart is not just the pizza itself, but the passion that the staff exudes. They take the time to explain menu options and ensure each customer's experience is a memorable one. This blend of quality food and customer care is what has kept Gatto's thriving through the years, even in its new location.
In conclusion, whether you're a local or just passing through Columbus, Gatto's Pizza promises a satisfying culinary experience that is resonant with flavors, nostalgic charm, and a welcoming atmosphere. Enjoy your pizza adventure at Gatto's Pizza, where every bite tells a delicious story!
Best sausage in the city! Order a sausage or pep/sausage/banana peppers is my favorite.
My grandma used to order Gatto's for delivery; it was her preferred pizza shop. I remember it being good pizza. Now I live in their delivery area, which I found out last night while craving pizza. I ordered while at a wine shop and thought I had plenty of time to make it home. They were actually earlier than stated but we were able to meet up after a few calls. It is even better than I remembered. The thin crust is so flavorful. The toppings and sauce are perfectly blended. When I heated some up the next day on the stove, it tasted just as good as it did freshly delivered. I'm so glad I can now have this wonderful pizza on a regular basis.
Had these at a party - tried the sausage & pepperoni as well as pepperoni & banana peppers, both really tasty! Quite oily but a good amount of ingredients on top, and the crust was thin and almost crunchy. Good amount of cheese without being too much, liked the pepperoni!
This Gatto's Pizza moved in to where the old Wildflower Cafe was, and I've finally given thus place a try! I ordered online and picked up; it took about 15 minutes later to be ready than stated, but they seemed to be very busy with lots of to go orders. In addition to ordering food and desserts, you can also order beer six packs which was a great discovery!
Stopped in today as we started this year's Columbus pizza trail and found a hidden gem. Very nice, clean pizzeria in the Clintonville neighborhood. Very pleasant staff who took time to explain their options for their pizza. We got a pizza with house made sausage and onions, and a meatball sub with house made meatballs. They also make their own sauce. You could tell the staff cared about their food and service.
Located on Indianola with a large parking lot. There are some tables inside for seating but ordering online and picking up was a breeze. Their pizza is what you would call Columbus pizza style, thinner crust and cut into squares. The crust was crunchy and nice but I did feel the pizza could have used a little more sauce so I would order extra next time.
Gatto's is still doing a great job after 50+years and a move to their new location. We had a classic pep and a made-to-order veg. We loved them both. Local beer choices and an ok wine list added to the experience. Heavy to go business but the sit down people, like us, was slow. We are fans!
Not cracker thin but a definite crunch to the bite. Great flavor and ratio of sauce, crust and toppings. Overall better than many pizzas at home in Chicago Really tasty pizza but really setup for carry out